Princeton Bans Professors from Dating Graduate Students Under New Policy
Quotes and attributions in this article, unless otherwise noted, are taken from minutes of the Council. Speakers therefore have a chance to contest or revise the way their comments are paraphrased. Still, the minutes should not be read as direct quotes, or as perfect reproductions of conversations that took place. More information about the minutes and Council can be found here. Diermeier frequently cites Harvard and Columbia universities, where graduate students recently unionized, as evidence that the collective bargaining process is an impenetrable snarl. In arguing against graduate student unionization, Diermeier has billed himself as a defender of faculty interests—protecting the autonomy of the advisor-student relationship, and shielding heterogeneous departments against the intrusion of a union. Some faculty agree with Diermeier that a union would interject itself between professors and graduate students, creating a burdensome layer of bureaucracy. Recently, other professors have raised questions about their lack of input in the broader question of unionization. The administration never sought a vote from faculty on GSU.
Michigan State considering ban on sex between professors and undergrads. Here’s why.
Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to continue reading. Please log in, or sign up for a new account to continue reading. Subscribe now to support local journalism and stay in the know with a full access subscription. A shower or two around the area early, then partly cloudy overnight. Low 54F.
This means, for example, that a professor may not date a student while that staff (including graduate teaching assistants) cannot engage in a dating or sexual.
While relationships between students and professors aren’t unheard of, they can be a source for all kinds of problems. A professor is in a position of authority over a student, whether or not he or she is that student’s teacher or supervisor, which makes any dating arrangement tricky at best. Ultimately, if the two are consenting adults there’s no scenario where it’s OK for a high school teacher to date a current student , there’s not much anyone can do to prevent them from pursuing a romantic relationship.
But expect there to be consequences. First things first: A student must be 18 years old to legally be able to consent to a relationship with an adult. Beyond that, some schools have specific rules about what to do if a student and a professor want to pursue a romantic relationship. Breaking those rules could jeopardize the professor’s job and the student’s status.
If you’re at an institution where there aren’t official rules about dating, there are most likely some guidelines or unofficial community expectations. Is it frowned upon? Is it OK to date a professor, so long as you’re not in one of his or her classes? Be aware that even if you’re not breaking any rules, your relationship, and how it’s perceived could cause problems. Even if the professor isn’t the student’s teacher when the relationship starts, problems could arise if the student ends up in the professor’s class later on.
As a member of the faculty, the professor holds power over the student.
Romantic and Sexual Relationships
This supply and demand imbalance is bound to produce jealousy among the older females professors who are generally losing out to the younger females grad students. To cope with this imbalance, the female professors lobby their university administration to ban student-professor relations in order to have less competition. Females are generally most attractive to potential partners during their grad student years mid 20’s.
Any student (undergraduate or graduate) who is currently participating as a prior to the effective date of this policy to the University offices specified above as.
Stay plugged into Penn with this daily newsletter rounding up all of the top headlines from top headlines from the DP, 34th Street, and Under the Button. The week’s top stories from the DP and beyond, meticulously curated for parents and alumni, and delivered into your inbox every Sunday morning. Subscribe to get the week’s top stories from The DP and beyond, meticulously curated for parents and alumni, delivered directly to your inbox.
A new policy banning all sexual relations between undergraduate students and faculty members at Penn went into effect on March The announcement is not unprecedented in the world of higher education. In fact, among other Ivy League institutions, Penn is relatively late to introduce this new policy shift. Dartmouth College, Harvard University, Yale University, Brown University, Princeton University, and Stanford University all have blanket prohibitions on undergraduate-faculty relationships for undergraduates, similar to the one Penn just implemented.
Credit: Julia Schorr Cornell’s current policy, approved in , has been “a topic of concern” for the last two years, and the university has created a Consensual Relationships Policy Committee, according to the university’s website. Yale’s policy states that undergraduates are “particularly vulnerable to the unequal institutional power inherent in the teacher-student relationship and the potential for coercion, because of their age and relative lack of maturity. The policy change also comes in the context of a wider trend in academia.
The New Republic
To improve your visit to our site, take a minute and upgrade your browser. My freshman American literature course presented me with many revelations, but one of the most indelible happened not inside the auditorium classroom where, twice a week, our professor stood onstage in front of more than a hundred year-olds.
Like many vaguely parental relationships, the pedagogic one can have a strong and unsettling erotic undertow. Like many young women, however, we were far from immune to the mystique of a man who can command the admiring attention of a crowd, and if he was like most men, he was sensible to the flattery of all those rapt faces. Yet at the root of this queasy dynamic was genuine intellectual excitement. His class set off a series of firecrackers in my understanding of books, ideas whose impact I can still recollect vividly.
Date Issued: January 1, Date Last Revised: May 1, between (1) a student and a faculty member, graduate teaching or research assistant, Relationships between faculty and students are particularly susceptible to exploitation.
Sexual or romantic relationships may raise concerns of conflict of interest, abuse of authority, favoritism, and unfair treatment when both people are in the MIT work or academic environment, and one person holds a position of power or authority over the other. These relationships may also affect others in the work or academic environment, undermining the integrity of their supervision and evaluation as well. These concerns exist even when the relationship is considered consensual by both individuals.
In some instances, consent may not be as freely given as the more senior person in the relationship believes. Because of the possible adverse effects on the other party and on their fellow students, co-workers, colleagues, and others, the Institute prohibits all faculty, other academic instructional staff, other employees, and other non-student members of the MIT community paid or unpaid from having sexual or romantic relationships with certain MIT students and employees, whether or not the relationship is consensual.
A summary of this policy is as follows, with more detail in the noted sections:. Where this policy imposes a duty to notify and recuse, that duty falls on the person in the position of power or authority in the relationship. Where required, notification and recusal must take place as soon as practical after any action has been taken by either party to establish a sexual or romantic relationship.
Faculty, other academic instructional staff , other employees, and other members of the MIT community other than MIT students are prohibited from having a sexual or romantic relationship with any undergraduate student at MIT. Such relationships with undergraduates are always prohibited. See Section 9. In addition, faculty members and other academic instructional staff may not exercise academic authority over any graduate student or other learner with whom they had a prior sexual or romantic relationship.
Can You Date Your RA, TA, Or Professor? Here’s How To Handle The Situation
R omantic relationships between university professors and their students are becoming less and less acceptable. Many of the new university policies that have emerged in the last few years have focused on undergraduates and how to better protect them, typically with a campus-wide ban on staff dating undergrads. But a number of universities also demand that faculty members do not start relationships with graduate students they supervise.
This month, Princeton University went further and declared that faculty members were no longer allowed to date any graduate student—even if the couple works in different departments. Pre-existing relationships are exempt from the new rule.
If a graduate student’s major professor departs from violence, dating violence and stalking. Graduate discussed with other students by professors or staff.
HR contacts. Employee Relations contacts. Purdue University is committed to maintaining an environment in which learning, discovery and engagement take place in a professional atmosphere of mutual respect and trust. Amorous Relationships can develop within the University community between faculty, students and staff. The disparity of power when an Amorous Relationship is between 1 a student and a faculty member, graduate teaching or research assistant, or any other University employee who has educational responsibility over the student, 2 a supervisor and subordinate, or 3 senior and junior colleagues in the same department or unit makes the individuals involved susceptible to exploitation.
Relationships between faculty and students are particularly susceptible to exploitation. The respect and trust accorded a member of the faculty by a student, as well as the power exercised by faculty in giving grades, approvals or recommendations for future study and employment, make voluntary consent by the student suspect.
Students dating lecturers: Why, how, and what are the consequences?
Steve Hunt was emotionally wrecked. Steve acted mortified, at first refusing to admit his son was right. He had feelings for a student. The two were married a year later, before Bridget, a Haddonfield native, became a senior. By the time of the wedding, they had weathered intense criticism on campus from friends, strangers, and colleagues. Until recently, many schools in Pennsylvania and New Jersey did not have such rules as well.
A romantic relationship between a professor and student is generally not a good idea, but here’s what Is It OK for College Students and Professors to Date? Avoid These Common Mistakes Students Make in Grad School.
In some ways, sex between students and their professors is part of the mythology of academia. It turns up regularly in film and literature. The scenario typically involves a young female student seduced by her older and more knowledgeable teacher. Historically, male professors have considered a campus full of available young women a perk of academia. Attitudes began to change in the s and s, with the rise of feminism and an increasing number of female scholars in academia.
Real policy changes did not occur until the late s and s, when courts said schools could be held liable in sexual harassment cases. Since then, many universities have begun to address student-professor dating. University fraternization rules are sometimes vague. It is a commonly held belief that everyone is considered an adult at the college level and should know where to draw the line.
At many schools, there are no formal rules about professors dating students. It is discouraged, but not prohibited. For most educators, there is an unwritten rule that getting involved with students is a bad idea. Nationally, universities have taken different approaches to the problem of professor-student relationships.